Gilthoniel's story by angel_of_beauty_and_light

Feb 28, 2006 11:28 AM by: Nemya chapter 14

Gee, thanks Ani >__>

I can't help things if I don't feel sad, really. Atleast my comment wasn't

OMG YOR STORY TOTALY SUX!!!1!!

Or something (this is not implying that your comments are like this, by the way. I just was making a point. Sorry Manning xP)

Feb 25, 2006 03:19 PM by: pink_lettuce_leaf chapter 14

*strangles Katy and Mel*

well.. actually all the wood elves are not dead, and also Silvan, Quenya and all the other elves can get on fine! I mean Tinuviel and Elladan love eachother..

and it WAS sad.

aargh their comments ruined the ending...

Feb 25, 2006 03:15 PM by: pink_lettuce_leaf chapter 13

*gives up and just strangles Katy*

Elves are immortal as in they don't die of old age, they can be killed in battle, by wounds or even by a broken heart- just like people!!!!

Feb 25, 2006 03:08 PM by: pink_lettuce_leaf chapter 11

Actually, only the descendants of Luthien Tinuviel (legendary one) are given the choice between immortality and mortality. Which is why Arwen's brothers are mortal.

Feb 25, 2006 02:55 PM by: pink_lettuce_leaf chapter 8

Here *points to Mel's comment* is the first sign of change. As you can see, Mel no longer uses the reserved, polite language which I was accustomed to and begins to act in a more outgoing way.

Seriously though, look at the difference

Feb 25, 2006 02:49 PM by: pink_lettuce_leaf chapter 6

Haldir may have been annoying, but it was really sad when he died! Like it is when anyone dies

*glares at someone*

Feb 25, 2006 02:47 PM by: pink_lettuce_leaf chapter 5

Oh God Katy, who cares? No elf acts like Tilly is said to

Feb 25, 2006 02:42 PM by: pink_lettuce_leaf chapter 3

*laughs* Young elves are so different to the elder elves, what I find funny is how it was supposed to be your seventeenth year and "Tinuviel is one of my oldest and dearest friends" I love it, either it is just your writing at the time/ human forgetfulness but for Tinuviel, even though you would be extremely important to her you would be no where near her oldest friend XD

sorry... lost the plot midway through that sentence.

Tinuviel wouldn't mind.

Feb 25, 2006 02:33 PM by: pink_lettuce_leaf chapter 2

and then again.. Tinuviel is older still XD I wonder how on earth they found the patience to talk to one another..

You wrote this a LONG time ago, I can tell.

Feb 25, 2006 02:29 PM by: pink_lettuce_leaf chapter 1

er... *wonders why on Earth there is no scarily hypernated comment from Mel*

I'm really bored, I think I read this ages ago without commenting but may just as well reread lol XD

I put up the scary random story, it was only a page long in Word. It needs more middle but I wasn't able to put it in.. I can't do middle XD But maybe after having my navel piercings I will be able to add more to my middle... aaah that was a confusing sentence..

Jul 12, 2005 01:52 PM by: Tillyenna chapter 14

Well done my freind, twas a good tale. and all the woodelves are dead, so I'm happy, and I end with my darling sweet Galandiel, so that makes me happy to. Its not a sad ending its a happy ending eveyone is with the people they love. I am, nims is (legolas kee hee) and Galdor and Feonor are happy together, and you, you are with findiel, so you are happy, pity about the poor bloody wolves though

Jul 12, 2005 01:50 PM by: Tillyenna chapter 13

awww, you're hardly immortal are you??? and yes I do have a heart of stone. its freaky though seing Lady galad crying

Jul 12, 2005 01:45 PM by: Tillyenna chapter 12

He's a traitor, get over him. GILTHONIEL you know the price of elven blood, he has spilt the blood of many an elf, those who do that are destined to die, unless it is, their own blood, unless it is, pure blood.

Jul 12, 2005 01:41 PM by: Tillyenna chapter 11

One who kills his own kin is not fit to be a high elf, no, not fit to be an elf at all. If he were of my family, I would force him to choose mortality, but no, only we have that privilidge, so instead, I would kill him.

Jul 12, 2005 01:36 PM by: Tillyenna chapter 10

ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha you have to marry a freaky creapy woodelf, a) hes from mirkwood, b) hes a slimeball and c) hes actually worse than one of nemya's 'freinds' and even worse than a buddy, thats gotta be bad

Jul 12, 2005 01:32 PM by: Tillyenna chapter 9

HA HA HA HA HA HA HA HA!!!!! down with the woodelf. Hee hee hee, he shall be punished, bwa ha ha ha ha ha

Jul 12, 2005 12:58 PM by: Tillyenna chapter 8

*agress with sis* yes there is alot of cheese, hmm but the woodelf is finally dead and gone. Why waste a good necklace?????

Jul 12, 2005 12:54 PM by: Tillyenna chapter 7

hmmm, there are reasons we dont get on, but I'll leave it at that, and you still havnt explained about findiel beind a not woodelf or (more likely) being ashamed of his woodelfness

Jul 12, 2005 12:51 PM by: Tillyenna chapter 6

i dunno, immortals, they just dont seem to stay immortal for very long, do they? hee hee hee *laughs as she remebers haldirs head being split in ttwo by an orcu axe*

Jul 12, 2005 12:46 PM by: Tillyenna chapter 5

me again, just found an impossibiltiy in your chapter, unless she is praying in her head, by blood rights gilthoniel is a wood lef, she must be becuase haldir is, so even though she is an honarary high elf, she still cannot say the word 'Elbereth' as that is a privilidge reserved only for high elves

Jul 12, 2005 12:43 PM by: Tillyenna chapter 4

*sniffs* okay I know I hate my brother, but you cant just leave him to die with you in a mood with him, even if he is haldir.

Jul 12, 2005 12:40 PM by: Tillyenna chapter 3

*throws up* how can anyone get that sentimental about a woodelf, and anyway, you cant fall inlove with him, not becuase he's Tinuviels brother, but...becuase daddy dearest has an arranged marriage for him and nimrodel
HA HA HA HA HA HA HA HA HA

Jul 3, 2005 05:38 AM by: Tillyenna chapter 2

I thought galargriel says: things that were, things that are and things that have not yet come to pass
*blushes at her tolkieniteness*
but that could just be me

May 10, 2005 11:13 AM by: Eoara chapter 14

i hate you. You make me cry. shoot. im doign it again.

May 8, 2005 02:04 PM by: Nemya chapter 14

*glomps you*
AWESOMENESS!!!! THANK YOU SOO MUCH FOR UPLOADING!!! YAYAYAAY! AMAZINGNESS!
it was so sad *sniff* okay, only joking. It wasnt sad. It was awesome though! Awesome!!!

Mar 24, 2005 10:23 AM by: Nemya chapter 10

PS: Galdor is a freak o.o

Mar 24, 2005 10:23 AM by: Nemya chapter 10

yay story story story story story!!!

Thank you sooo much for uploading!!! *glomps*

Now pleeeaaaasee write more!! And could Nimrodel be in it??? *pesters*

awesomeness!!! NOW WRITE MOOOOOORE!

Mar 16, 2005 01:03 AM by: Nemya chapter 8

*BIG glomp*

yayness!! thanks again for uploading!! I still dont believe you chucked the other story in the bin ;_;...
anyways, there is a lot of PURE CHEESE, but hey, its awesome so keep it that way.
Im not going as far as Kara by saying that I was crying, because I wasnt, I was laughing at the cheese. Oh well. XD

NOW WRITE MORE SCUMMEEEEEEE!!!

Mar 15, 2005 01:13 PM by: Eoara chapter 8

manning, its soo good. im like wow. Omg, im crying
its sooooo sad. and sweet. k i seriously am crying.....oww its making my throat hurt more. kk. i reelly need to write my story now, dont i!

Mar 13, 2005 01:24 PM by: angel_of_beauty_and_light chapter 5

Well Tillyenna (sorry if I spelt your name wrong in the story) there is much more to Findiel than anyone thinks. This will be written about in another chapter. Not much is known about him by anyone (except me, but then I created him) and he has a very dark past. He doesn't like to be called a woodelf because he isn't a woodelf, basically.
I will write his story out sometime, because if I don't then Nemya will bash me, as she did until I put the story up!
I hope that answers your question, if not then ask me again some other time.
Big Lobe
Mei

Mar 13, 2005 06:18 AM by: Tillyenna chapter 5

I dont understand, well I do understand actually, Findiel doesnt like bieng a woodelf *spits* well i can understand, becuase I wouldnt want to be one either, hmmm dya recon I should put tillyenna up?
tilz
xxx

Mar 13, 2005 04:55 AM by: Nemya chapter 8

bweeeee back again :3

nargy write more Manning!! PLEASE???

*adds story and you to faves*^^

Mar 12, 2005 01:20 AM by: Nemya chapter 8

yay! *glomps* awesomeness!!! now PLEASE write more? *begs*

Mar 11, 2005 02:43 PM by: angel_of_beauty_and_light chapter 3

Hmm, thanks Nemya. I know you know who the real Findiel is but if you say anything then you will die! You will die, you will die, you will die!
Oh, thank you for saying it was amazing *glomps*.

Mar 11, 2005 02:07 PM by: Nemya chapter 3

uh. It didnt show my whole comment :K Well, Manning, write more!! My life depends on it! And yay, looks like Im not stuck with Legolas this time! *celebrates*

I KNOW WHO THE REAL FINDIEL IS!!! BWA HA HA!!!!!